Supreme Court of Canada Releases Decision in Redwater


On January 31, 2019, the Supreme Court of Canada released its decision in Orphan Well Association, Alberta Energy Regulator v. Grant Thornton Limited and ATB Financial.1 This important decision may have profound implications, potentially limiting the ability of oil and gas producers to secure credit and impairing the effectiveness of the insolvency system where debtors have significant regulatory obligations. Regulators may now argue that regulatory obligations have been vaulted to a super-priority status. Where those obligations exceed the value of the estate, and the transfer of assets is subject to regulatory control, it is unclear whether those assets could be sold in an insolvency process. Indeed, it is uncertain whether there would be a point to an insolvency process in those circumstances. This impact may well extend beyond the oil and gas industry to other regulated industries.

The case examined the intersection between insolvency law and provincial regulatory laws for the oil and natural gas industry. At issue were two points: (1) whether certain aspects of Alberta’s oil and gas regulatory regime conflict with section 14.06 of the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (the BIA) and are therefore inoperative under the constitutional doctrine of federal paramountcy; and (2) whether environmental remediation obligations under the Alberta regulatory regime constitute monetary obligations subject to the BIA and its priority rules. Specifically, the Court examined whether a receiver can disclaim the debtor’s interest in unsellable real property affected by environmental liabilities, sell the remaining assets, and distribute the net proceeds in accordance with the priorities set out in the BIA.

In a 5-to-2 decision, the majority of the Court determined that: