Trans Mountain Pipeline Approval Upheld Using New Standard of Review Principles


On February 4, 2020, the Federal Court of Appeal in Coldwater Indian Band et al. v. Attorney General of Canada et al.1 considered whether to uphold the Order in Council approving the Trans Mountain Expansion Project (Project) against claims that Canada had failed to appropriately consult and accommodate Indigenous concerns.

In upholding the authorization, the Court applied new principles from the Supreme Court of Canada (SCC) for reviewing regulatory and Crown decisions, including decisions relating to the Crown’s duty to consult. These principles, set out in a trilogy of SCC decisions released in December 2019, emphasize that deference must be given to Crown decision makers, who are to be evaluated on a standard of reasonableness. In particular, deference is owed to the decision maker where the Crown decision does not suffer from errors in reasoning or logical deficiencies, and where there is “a chain of reasoning progressing from a reasonable view of the evidence before it to the plausible conclusions.” 2

The Court concluded that “the decision of the Governor in Council was reasonable” within the first 30 pages of its reasons.3 In the remaining 65 pages, the Court took the unnecessary step of also demonstrating that the decision of the Governor in Council met the more stringent ‘correctness’ standard. This unnecessary analysis was undertaken to “defuse any suggestion that the Court did not consider the applicants’ submission.”4

More Information

For more information, please contact the authors of this article or any  member of our Aboriginal Law team.