Inside Insurance: Duty of Honest Performance in Contractual Relationships – Practical Implications for the Insurance Industry


Welcome to our Inside Insurance series, developed to provide topical, succinct, and practical insights that address real issues in-house counsel and other insurance and reinsurance industry executives face on a regular basis. As always, we are here to help.

In December 2020, the Supreme Court of Canada revisited1 the duty of honest performance doctrine (or duty of good faith doctrine), which it introduced in 20142 (the Doctrine). Much has been written about the Doctrine generally, and these two cases specifically, so we will skip a lengthy and complex analysis here.

What is important to appreciate is that the Doctrine obligates each party to a contract to perform their respective rights and obligations under that contract honestly. Practically, this means party A may not mislead party B materially, even where party A is exercising its rights and performing its obligations exactly as the contract provides. Furthermore, party A’s failure to act honestly will lead to an increased risk of liability for damages for party B’s loss of opportunity as a result of relying on Party A’s misleading representations.

More Information

If you have any questions or would like to discuss anything addressed here, please do not hesitate to reach out to any member of our Insurance and Reinsurance Group.