Not the Optimum Result? Shoppers Drug Mart Franchise Litigation Leads to Mixed Success


Earlier this year, a milestone was reached in a long-running franchise class action, Spina v. Shoppers Drug Mart Inc. The Court decided competing summary judgment motions brought by the plaintiffs and defendant franchisor drug store chain in respect of the franchisees’ claims that Shoppers owed them substantial sums for the non-payment of professional allowances and the overpayment of various fees. The results of the motions for summary judgment were mixed, as the plaintiff succeeded on some claims but were defeated on others.

To summarize the results:

  • The plaintiff failed to establish that Shoppers breached its contractual and good faith obligations as a result of the imposition of fees on its franchisees related to the Optimum loyalty plan program;
  • The plaintiff also did not succeed in its claim that Shoppers breached its contractual and good faith obligations by charging franchisees fees in excess of actual costs in respect of service and equipment leasing fees;
  • The plaintiff did not succeed in its claim that Shoppers was unjustly enriched by certain inventory and procurement policies imposed on franchisees. However, the Court did hold that Shoppers may have breached its statutory duty of fair dealing or its common law duty of good faith in respect of those inventory and procurement policies. That said, the Court also held that such claims were individual and could not be determined on a class-wide basis; and
  • The plaintiff succeeded on its claim that Shoppers’ retention of professional allowances constituted a breach of contract and a breach of the statutory and common law duties of good faith, but only in respect of franchisees that operated under certain older contracts that did not specifically address this particular unique revenue source.

More Information

For more information, please contact the author of this article or any member of our Franchise Group.