Supreme Court of Canada Confirms Arbitration Clauses Enforceable Against Businesses Claims


Business customers of Telus cannot avoid the terms of a mandatory arbitration clause by joining a class action with consumers who are not bound by the clause, the Supreme Court of Canada recently held, in its highly anticipated decision in Telus Communications Inc. v. Wellman, released April 4, 2019. The decision has implications for businesses that use arbitration clauses in their contracts and establishes that such clauses will generally be upheld in the commercial context, and can be used to avoid class actions in that context.

Background

Wellman filed a class action against Telus alleging that customers of Telus had been overcharged under their per-minute plan contracts as a result of undisclosed billing practices. The contracts included a mandatory arbitration clause to resolve all claims arising out of or in relation to the contract by arbitration. The class action involved claims by both consumers and business customers.