Uber Decision Does Not Necessarily Deliver Unconscionability to Franchise Arbitrations


The Supreme Court of Canada recently found that the arbitration provision used by popular ridesharing service, Uber Technologies, Inc. (Uber), in its standard form agreement with its drivers was invalid and unenforceable under the common law doctrine of unconscionability due to the substantial up-front costs associated with commencing an arbitration which effectively prevent drivers from pursuing claims. The decision paves the way for the drivers to pursue a class action in Ontario courts seeking a declaration that they are employees of Uber and relief for breaches of Ontario’s Employment Standards Act, 2000 (the ESA). The Court’s reformulation of the test for unconscionability may have wider ranging impacts for the use of arbitration in franchise agreements.

Background to the Proposed Class Action and Stay Motion

In January 2017, Toronto UberEats driver David Heller commenced a proposed class action on behalf of Ontario Uber drivers, which alleged that he and his fellow putative class members are employees of Uber, rather than independent contractors, and therefore entitled to the benefits and protections of the ESA. The claim seeks a total of $400 million in damages on behalf of the proposed class for alleged breaches of contract, breaches of the ESA, negligence and unjust enrichment.

More Information

For more information, please contact the author of this article or any member of our Franchise Law Group.