Cassels Successfully Defeats Certification Motion for Class Action Brought by Major Junior Hockey League Players; Court Leaves Path Open for Individual Claims Process


Cassels successfully responded to a certification motion for a proposed class action against the Canadian Hockey League (“CHL”), the Ontario Hockey League (“OHL”), the Western Hockey League (“WHL”), the Quebec Major Junior Hockey League (“QMJHL”), and their 60 teams. The claim alleged players experienced widespread and ritualized hazing, racism, homophobia, sexual, and physical abuse. The action and motion were brought by three representative plaintiffs, all former Major Junior hockey players.

The defendants brought two cross motions. The first one alleged that since the three representative plaintiffs only played in five teams during their careers, they had no claim against the remaining 55 teams and the action could not proceed against those defendants, applying a principle first articulated fully in an Ontario decision, Ragoonanan (the “Ragoonanan motion”).1 The second motion alleged the Ontario court did not have jurisdiction over the defendants located outside of Ontario, the WHL, QMJHL, and their 40 teams.

The Court’s decision was released on February 3, 2023.2