What a Pickle: Unauthorized Deli Franchisees Ordered to Pay Trademark Damages, but Escape Copyright Liability


In Dunn’s Famous International Holdings Inc. v. Devine,1 the franchisor obtained default judgment for trademark infringement and related relief against unauthorized “franchisees” who had acquired their franchises from a party that had claimed, unsuccessfully, to own the franchise system. However, the franchisor’s copyright claim failed because it could not prove that it owned the copyright in its webpages. Although the facts of the case are unique, its lessons may apply more broadly, including where a former franchisee fails to de-identify. It is also a helpful reminder to franchisors to pay close attention to copyright ownership, especially when entering Canada from other countries where different rules might apply.

Background

Dunn’s is a multi-generational family business that operates in the space of retail food product development, marketing, licensing and wholesale distribution. The case arose out of a dispute between two ownership groups that both claimed to own the trademarks and tradenames in question (the DUNN’s Trademarks) and to be the rightful franchisor of the Dunn’s Famous brand.

More Information

For more information, please contact the authors of this article or any member of our Franchise Group.