Not Enough to File and Smile: BC Supreme Court Refuses to Certify Class Proceeding, Confirms That Low Bar Does Not Mean No Bar


The British Columbia Supreme Court has held that a class action certification application is not merely a “file, smile and certify” exercise, and that certification is intended to be a meaningful screening device.

KEY TAKEAWAYS

  • The British Columbia Supreme Court will not permit an uncritical “file, smile and certify” process in class proceedings. Plaintiffs must prove that they meet the low threshold for certification. The Court may also scrutinize evidence where necessary at the certification stage to ensure that all requirements are met.
  • Expert methodology should be grounded in a realistic prospect of demonstrating harm on a class-wide basis at trial. This may require the plaintiffs to lead evidence regarding the availability of data required by their methodology, especially where sources are publically available. Experts must clearly demonstrate how identified data sources will be sufficient to yield expected results using the proposed methodology.