Much Needed Relief: Ontario Courts Address Anti-Black Racism in the Context of Relief from Forfeiture


In a decision recently upheld by the Ontario Court of Appeal,1 the Ontario Superior Court of Justice in Elias Restaurant v. Keele Sheppard Plaza Inc.2 took judicial notice of anti-black racism and factored in racial prejudice on the part of a landlord to grant a tenant the equitable remedy of relief from forfeiture.

The tenant, Elias Restaurant, operates a family-run restaurant serving African and Caribbean food from its premises in a shopping plaza in Toronto under a lease with the landlord, Keele Sheppard Plaza Inc. The term of the lease was originally for five years and the lease held that the tenant had two renewal options to extend the term by written notice to the landlord at least six months prior to the expiry of the relevant term. Although the tenant failed to strictly adhere to the terms of the notice provision, the tenant made significant efforts both before and after such notice deadline to contact the landlord and communicate its intention to extend the term. The landlord kept the tenant in an overholding position from August 2, 2017 to May 28, 2020, at which time it issued a notice of termination to the tenant. The tenant then sought relief from forfeiture from the court.

Relief from forfeiture, originally an equitable form of relief, is also found in Ontario legislation under section 20 of the Commercial Tenancies Act and more broadly under section 98 of the Courts of Justice Act (CJA). A court may grant relief against a forfeiture that, although consistent with the terms of an agreement, would nevertheless cause an inequitable consequence on the party that breached the agreement. Generally speaking, courts have found it appropriate to utilize their discretionary power to grant such relief where the interests of the party pursuing forfeiture, in this case the landlord seeking re-entry into the premises, can be vindicated without upholding the right of re-entry.3 The court’s power to provide such relief is fact-specific. In the event that parties do not act in good faith in accordance with reasonable commercial standards, the court under its CJA discretion may grant relief based on: (1) the conduct of the applicant seeking relief, (2) the gravity of the breaches, and (3) the disparity between the value of the property forfeited and the damage caused by the breach,4 provided the court has determined that it is possible to avoid future breaches.

More Information

For further information, please contact Ardy Mohajer and Kwaku Tabi of the Real Estate & Development Group, and co-chairs of the firm’s Asian Affinity Group and Black Affinity Group, respectively, or any other member of the Real Estate & Development team.