Bustin Outside the Traditional Limits of Liability? Court Declines to Strike Claim Brought by Bystander for Witnessing a Motor Vehicle Accident


In the recent decision in Bustin v Quaranto, the Ontario Superior Court of Justice dismissed a defendant’s motion to strike a claim brought by a bystander alleging personal injuries arising from merely witnessing a double-fatality motor vehicle accident.1 The decision demonstrates that the Court is not willing to dismiss cases like this on their face, suggesting that manufacturers’ potential liability arising from incidents involving their products could potentially expand further than originally thought.

The Facts

The plaintiff witnessed a motor vehicle accident involving two vehicles and three people. Two occupants of one vehicle died in the accident. The defendant, who survived the accident, was the driver and sole occupant of the other vehicle. The plaintiff, who was not an occupant of either of the involved vehicles, brought a claim in negligence for personal injuries arising from witnessing the accident as a bystander. The claim alleges that the plaintiff “suffered physical and mental injuries akin to or notionally equivalent to being struck by the [d]efendant’s vehicle in the collision”2 for which the defendant is alleged to be liable.

More Information

For more information, please contact the authors of this article or any member of our Product Liability Group.